Rookie cards · Hockey
Sidney Crosby Rookie Card Value
As of November 10, 2026, Sidney Crosby rookie cards have a median eBay asking price of $42.49 across 99 live listings, with most listed between $9.99 and $141. Raw copies ask around $24.99 and PSA 10s around $260. The most expensive listed right now is "2005-06 Upper Deck #201 Sidney Crosby BGS 9.5" at $3,000.
The most-listed Sidney Crosby rookie cards are the 2005-06 Upper Deck #51, 2005-06 Fleer #251 and 2005-06 Upper Deck #285. Typical asking prices run from about $10 to $150. A PSA 10 usually lists for about 12× the same card raw.
Listings as of · eBay asking prices, refreshed every 6 hours · How prices work
Listings link to eBay. As an eBay Partner, Card Value may earn a commission when you buy through these links.

Top listing right now
Median ask
$42.49
99 live listings
What's popular
How much are Sidney Crosby rookie cards worth?
Most-listed sidney crosby rookie cards
- 12005-06 Upper Deck #51typ. $15
- 22005-06 Fleer #251typ. $450
- 32005-06 Upper Deck #285typ. $85
- 42005-06 Upper Deck #133typ. $55
- 52005-06 Upper Deck #393typ. $95
Grading premium
12×
A PSA 10 typically lists for this multiple of the same card raw.
Chase cards
What are the most expensive Sidney Crosby rookie cards?
#1BGS 9.52005-06 Upper Deck #201 Sidney Crosby BGS 9.5
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$3,000Buy it now
#2PSA 9MINTSidney Crosby 2005-06 Fleer Ultra Gold Rookie #251 Penguins HOF RC PSA 9 Mint
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$870Buy it now
#3PSA 10GEM MT2009-10 UPPER DECK The Cup Sidney Crosby #1 /249 Penguins PSA 10 POP 1
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$545Buy it now
#4BGS 9.52005-06 Fleer Ultra Rookie Sidney Crosby #251 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Rookie RC
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$450Buy it now
#5PSA 10GEM MT2005 UPPER DECK DIARY OF A PHENOM #DP17 SIDNEY CROSBY ROOKIE RC PENGUINS PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$450Buy it now
#6PSA 8NM-MT2025-26 Upper Deck- Monumental Moments SIDNEY CROSBY Signed Card PSA 8/AUTO 9
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$4000 bids · ends Nov 10
#71/1 SIDNEY CROSBY RC 🔥 2005-06 UPPER DECK ROOKIE SSP 🔥 PENINI ONE OF ONE ART
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$400Buy it now
#82005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby ROOKIE GEMS #193 Black Diamond Quadruple
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$399Buy it now
On the market
More Sidney Crosby rookie cards for sale
PSA 62005 Upper Deck Power Play Sidney Crosby Rookie Card #133 PSA 6 Penguins
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$55.00Buy it now
PSA 8NM-MT2005 Upper Deck Power Play Sidney Crosby Rookie Card #133 PSA 8 Penguins RC
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$99.00Buy it now
BGS 9.5Sidney Crosby 2005-06 Upper Deck Phenomenal Beginning #10 Graded BGS 9.5
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$32.50Buy it now
SIDNEY CROSBY 2005-06 Fleer Ultra #251 Rookie RC Pittsburgh Penguins
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$200Buy it now
2005 Break Through Prospects Draft Premium Sidney Crosby /2005 RC Team Canada
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$14.99Buy it now
PSA 10GEM MTSidney Crosby Rookie Card 2005-06 Upper Deck McDonald's #51 (RC) Penguins PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$295Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck Phenomenal Beginning Sidney Crosby Exclusive Gold Edition #18
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$4.50Buy it now
Upper Deck 2005-06 Trilogy Sidney Crosby Penguins Rookie Premiere #211 /999
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$1696 bids · ends Nov 11
PSA 9MINT2005 In The Game Heroes & Prospects #337 Sidney Crosby PSA 9 Fresh Grades JL
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$39.99Buy it now
PSA 9MINT2005-06 Upper Deck McDonald's Sidney Crosby Rookie RC #51 Penguins PSA 9 (37)
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$0.990 bids · ends Nov 14
2005/06 Upper Deck Collectibles Die Cast Sidney Crosby Rookie #DCSC1 Penguins
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$33.00Buy it now
2022-23 Topps Chrome NHL Sticker Collection Sidney Crosby & Evgeni Malkin /50 SP
New · + shipping on eBay
$40.00Buy it now
PSA 7NMUpper Deck 2021-22 Credentials Pro Visions Sidney Crosby Penguins #1 PSA 7
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$70.00Buy it now
2023-24 UD ICE FROZEN IN ICE FI-23 PENGUINS SIDNEY CROSBY sealed
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$68.00Buy it now
PSA 9MINT2005-06 Upper Deck McDonald's Sidney Crosby Rookie RC #51 Penguins PSA 9 (03)
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$0.990 bids · ends Nov 14
2005 Ultimate Collection Debut Threads Jersey 146/250 Sidney Crosby Rookie DTJSC
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$275Buy it now
PSA 10GEM MT2005 UPPER DECK ROOKIE CLASS #1 SIDNEY CROSBY RC PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$17917 bids · ends Nov 12
SIDNEY CROSBY - 2003 ROOKIE REVIEW CARD # 56 - PITTSBURGH PENGUINS - NHL
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$6.00Buy it now
2004 Rookie Review #104 Sidney Crosby Penguins
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$3.99Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck Victory - Rookies Sidney Crosby #285 (RC)
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$229Buy it now
BGS 9.5BGS 9.5 Gem Mint SIDNEY CROSBY 2005/06 UPPER DECK ROOKIE CLASS *CRACKED HOLDER*
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$5.524 bids · ends Nov 12
2005-06 McDonald's Upper Deck Hockey #51 Sidney Crosby (RC)
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$24.99Buy it now
2005-06 Parkhurst Sidney Crosby RC #657 Pittsburgh Penguins Rookie
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$85.00Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck - Power Play - Sidney Crosby #133 RC
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$42.49Buy it now
Parallels & grades
Sidney Crosby value by version
| Version | Listed | From | Median | PSA 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Black | 1 | $399 | $399 | — |
| Orange | 1 | $300 | $300 | $300 |
| Red | 1 | $220 | $220 | — |
| Base / other/6 | 86 | $0.99 | $46.22 | $250 |
| Gold | 10 | $0.99 | $4.50 | — |
Grouped from live listing titles · asking prices
Card back
Sidney Crosby value FAQ
- How much are Sidney Crosby rookie cards worth?
- Most Sidney Crosby rookie cards list between about $10 and $150 on eBay. condition, grade and print run move the value most.
- Which Sidney Crosby rookie cards are the most popular?
- By number of listings, the most popular are the 2005-06 Upper Deck #51, 2005-06 Fleer #251, 2005-06 Upper Deck #285 and 2005-06 Upper Deck #133.
- Are Sidney Crosby rookie cards worth anything?
- Yes. A typical Sidney Crosby rookie card lists for around $40, and graded, numbered or autographed copies go well beyond that.
- Is a PSA 10 Sidney Crosby rookie card worth more?
- Yes. Comparing the same card, PSA 10 copies typically list for about 12× the price of a raw (ungraded) copy.