Rookie cards · Hockey
Sidney Crosby Rookie Card Value
As of November 4, 2026, Sidney Crosby rookie cards have a median eBay asking price of $53.00 across 99 live listings, with most listed between $15.00 and $200. Raw copies ask around $24.97 and PSA 10s around $260. The most expensive listed right now is "Sidney Crosby 2005-06 Fleer Ultra Gold Rookie #251 Penguins HOF RC PSA 9 Mint" at $870.
The most-listed Sidney Crosby rookie cards are the 2005-06 Fleer #251, 2005-06 Upper Deck #101 Bee Hive and 2005-06 Upper Deck #51. Typical asking prices run from about $15 to $200. A PSA 10 usually lists for about 15× the same card raw. The Red parallel is the most valuable common version, listing around $300.
Listings as of · eBay asking prices, refreshed every 6 hours · How prices work
Listings link to eBay. As an eBay Partner, Card Value may earn a commission when you buy through these links.
Top listing right now
Median ask
$53.00
99 live listings
What's popular
How much are Sidney Crosby rookie cards worth?
Most-listed sidney crosby rookie cards
- 12005-06 Fleer #251typ. $700
- 22005-06 Upper Deck #101 Bee Hivetyp. $325
- 32005-06 Upper Deck #51typ. $150
- 42005-06 Upper Deck #285typ. $85
- 52005-06 Upper Deck #1typ. $45
Grading premium
15×
A PSA 10 typically lists for this multiple of the same card raw.
Chase cards
What are the most expensive Sidney Crosby rookie cards?
- #1PSA 9MINT
Sidney Crosby 2005-06 Fleer Ultra Gold Rookie #251 Penguins HOF RC PSA 9 Mint
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$870Buy it now 
#2PSA 10GEM MT2005-06 Sidney Crosby PSA 10 Fleer Ultra #251 Rookie Penguins SSP Pop 345 Hockey
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$700Buy it now
#32005-06 Fleer Ultra Sidney Crosby Rookie Gold Medallion SSP RC #251
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$688Buy it now
#42011 Panini Dominion Engravatures Stanley Cup Champ Sidney Crosby 9/10 #5 POP 1
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$650Buy it now
#52005-06 Upper Deck Bee Hive - Sidney Crosby #101 Red (RC)
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$487Buy it now
#6BGS 9.52005-06 Fleer Ultra Rookie Sidney Crosby #251 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT Rookie RC
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$450Buy it now
#7PSA 10GEM MT2005 UPPER DECK DIARY OF A PHENOM #DP17 SIDNEY CROSBY ROOKIE RC PENGUINS PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$450Buy it now
#8PSA 10GEM MTSIDNEY CROSBY 2017-28 O-PEE-CHEE PLATINUM, SEISMIC GOLD - #10/50, PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$4049 bids · ends Nov 3
On the market
More Sidney Crosby rookie cards for sale
PSA 62005 Upper Deck Power Play Sidney Crosby Rookie Card #133 PSA 6 Penguins
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$55.00Buy it now
1/1 SIDNEY CROSBY RC 🔥 2005-06 UPPER DECK ROOKIE SSP 🔥 PENINI ONE OF ONE ART
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$400Buy it now
05-06 UPPER DECK ROOKIE CLASS SIDNEY CROSBY
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$27.8915 bids · ends Nov 3
PSA 10GEM MT2005 IN THE GAME HEROES & PROSPECTS #337 SIDNEY CROSBY RC PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$45.00Buy it now
PSA 10GEM MTSIDNEY CROSBY 2016-17 UPPER DECK SERIES ONE, GOLD RAINBOW FOIL, PSA 10!!
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$80.0023 bids · ends Nov 3
2005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby / Alex Ovechkin Rookie Showdown 3D #RS-SCAO
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$44.99Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck Sidney Crosby ROOKIE GEMS #193 Black Diamond Quadruple
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$399Buy it now
SIDNEY CROSBY ROOKIE CARD 2005 Upper Deck PHENOMENAL BEGINNING Penguin Hockey RC
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$0.990 bids · ends Nov 7
Sidney Crosby 2005 Draft Day Premier Sports Publication Rookie Penguins (RC)
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$18.00Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck - Rookie Threads Sidney Crosby #RT-SC (MEM, RC)
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$141Buy it now
Sidney Crosby Alexander Ovechkin 2006 Upper Deck Rookie Showdown Card RS-SCAO
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$49.95Buy it now
05-06 FLEER ULTRA SIDNEY CROSBY DIFFERENCE MAKERS JERSEY ROOKIE
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$60.00Buy it now
2005-06 In the Game Heroes and Prospects - Sidney Crosby #361 (RC)
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$45.00Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck - Diary of a Phenom Sidney Crosby #DP9 (RC)
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.00Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck - Diary of a Phenom Sidney Crosby #DP30 (RC)
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.00Buy it now
PSA 10GEM MTSidney Crosby Rookie Card 2005-06 Upper Deck McDonald's #51 (RC) Penguins PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$310Buy it now
BGS 92005 Upper Deck Rookie Class Sidney Crosby RC Mint BGS 9
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$68.95Buy it now
Sidney Crosby Rookie Upper deck 2006 Phenomenal Beginings Card # 13
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$4.50Buy it now
Upper Deck 2005-06 Rookie Showdown #RS-SCAO Crosby Ovechkin PSA #41290056
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$140Buy it now
2005-06 Upper Deck Victory - Rookies Sidney Crosby #285 (RC)
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$229Buy it now
Rookie Showdown Alex Ovechkin, Sidney Crosby 2005-06 Upper Deck - #RS-SCAO (RC)
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$89.99Buy it now
PSA 10GEM MT2005 Upper Deck McDonald's Sidney Crosby Rookie #51 PSA 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$271Buy it now
SIDNEY CROSBY ROOKIE CARD Pittsbugh Penguin 2005 Upper Deck RARE GOLD VERSION RC
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$0.990 bids · ends Nov 4
2005 UD Sidney Crosby PB GOLD 21 Card ROOKIE Set+JUMBO RC! Look for $1,500 AUTO!
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$99.95Buy it now
Parallels & grades
Sidney Crosby value by version
| Version | Listed | From | Median | PSA 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Black | 1 | $399 | $399 | — |
| Blue | 1 | $356 | $356 | — |
| Red | 4 | $220 | $300 | $300 |
| Orange | 2 | $3.95 | $152 | $300 |
| Gold | 9 | $0.99 | $80.00 | $242 |
| Base / other/6 | 82 | $0.01 | $48.98 | $226 |
Grouped from live listing titles · asking prices
Card back
Sidney Crosby value FAQ
- How much are Sidney Crosby rookie cards worth?
- Most Sidney Crosby rookie cards list between about $15 and $200 on eBay. Parallels like the Red ask more (around $300), and condition, grade and print run move the value most.
- Which Sidney Crosby rookie cards are the most popular?
- By number of listings, the most popular are the 2005-06 Fleer #251, 2005-06 Upper Deck #101 Bee Hive, 2005-06 Upper Deck #51 and 2005-06 Upper Deck #285.
- Are Sidney Crosby rookie cards worth anything?
- Yes. A typical Sidney Crosby rookie card lists for around $55, and graded, numbered or autographed copies go well beyond that.
- Is a PSA 10 Sidney Crosby rookie card worth more?
- Yes. Comparing the same card, PSA 10 copies typically list for about 15× the price of a raw (ungraded) copy.