CardValue

Card value

Patrick Mahomes Supernatural Card Value

As of November 7, 2026, Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards have a median eBay asking price of $3.99 across 100 live listings, with most listed between $2.25 and $15.00. Raw copies ask around $3.99 and PSA 10s around $250. The most expensive listed right now is "23 Panini- Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II Cracked Ice PSA 9 15/25 Jersey Match" at $250.

The most-listed Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards are the 2024 Contenders #1 and 2023 Contenders #10. Typical asking prices run from about $2 to $15. A PSA 10 usually lists for about 13× the same card raw. The Gold parallel is the most valuable common version, listing around $150.

Listings as of · eBay asking prices, refreshed every 6 hours · How prices work

Listings link to eBay. As an eBay Partner, Card Value may earn a commission when you buy through these links.

23 Panini- Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II Cracked Ice PSA 9  15/25 Jersey Match
$250PSA 9

Top listing right now

Median ask

$3.99

100 live listings

What's popular

How much are Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards worth?

Most-listed patrick mahomes supernatural cards

  1. 12024 Contenders #1typ. $20
  2. 22023 Contenders #10typ. $15

Grading premium

13×

A PSA 10 typically lists for this multiple of the same card raw.

Chase cards

What are the most expensive Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards?

On the market

More Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards for sale

Parallels & grades

Patrick Mahomes Supernatural value by version

VersionListedFromMedianPSA 10
Cracked Ice1$250$250—
Gold2$64.99$158—
Refractor2$2.99$48.99—
Rainbow1$33.74$33.74—
Holo1$31.49$31.49—
Pink3$15.00$22.00—
Silver2$3.00$16.50—
Green6$1.99$4.00—

Grouped from live listing titles · asking prices

Card back

Patrick Mahomes Supernatural value FAQ

How much are Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards worth?
Most Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards list between about $2 and $15 on eBay. Parallels like the Gold ask more (around $150), and condition, grade and print run move the value most.
Which Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards are the most popular?
By number of listings, the most popular are the 2024 Contenders #1 and 2023 Contenders #10.
Are Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards worth anything?
Most list for a few dollars. The value is in rare parallels, low print runs, autographs and high grades (the Gold version lists around $150).
Is a PSA 10 Patrick Mahomes Supernatural card worth more?
Yes. Comparing the same card, PSA 10 copies typically list for about 13× the price of a raw (ungraded) copy.