Card value
Patrick Mahomes Supernatural Card Value
As of November 4, 2026, Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards have a median eBay asking price of $4.20 across 100 live listings, with most listed between $2.50 and $15.00. The most expensive listed right now is "2024 Patrick Mahomes 15/25 Panini Supernatural Cracked Ice Jersey Match" at $350.
The most-listed Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards are the 2024 Contenders #1 and 2023 Contenders #10. Typical asking prices run from about $3 to $15. The Cracked Ice parallel is the most valuable common version, listing around $325.
Listings as of · eBay asking prices, refreshed every 6 hours · How prices work
Listings link to eBay. As an eBay Partner, Card Value may earn a commission when you buy through these links.
Top listing right now
Median ask
$4.20
100 live listings
What's popular
How much are Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards worth?
Most-listed patrick mahomes supernatural cards
- 12024 Contenders #1typ. $20
- 22023 Contenders #10typ. $15
Chase cards
What are the most expensive Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards?
- #1
2024 Patrick Mahomes 15/25 Panini Supernatural Cracked Ice Jersey Match
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$350Buy it now 
#2PSA 9MINT23 Panini- Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II Cracked Ice PSA 9 15/25 Jersey Match
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$300Buy it now
#3SGC 9RARE 2021 Panini Contenders Supernatural Patrick Mahomes #SN-PMA Sapphire SGC 9
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$300Buy it now
#4SGC 102023 Contenders PATRICK MAHOMES II SUPERNATURAL SGC 10
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$199Buy it now
#5PSA 9MINTPanini 2024 Contenders Supernatural #1 Patrick Mahomes II PSA 9 Chiefs
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$150Buy it now
#6Patrick Mahomes II 2025 Topps Signature Orange Lava Refractor 38/50 Case Hit SSP
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$99.95Buy it now
#7Patrick Mahomes Rare Hyper Refractor Investment Card SSP Panini Chiefs MVP QB
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$94.99Buy it now
#8Patrick Mahomes II 2024 Panini Contenders Supernatural Case Hit SSP
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$79.95Buy it now
On the market
More Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards for sale
2022 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #SN-PMA Emerald
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.75Buy it now
2024 Panini Contenders Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #1 Disco Parallel Chiefs
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$7.99Buy it now
2021 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #SN-PMA Ruby
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.50Buy it now
Panini 2022 Contenders Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II Emerald Chiefs #SN-PMA
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.99Buy it now
Panini 2022 Contenders Football Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II Chiefs #SN-PMA
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$1.00Buy it now
2022 Panini Contenders #SN-PMA Patrick Mahomes II Supernatural Green
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$4.59Buy it now
2023 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #10
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$15.00Buy it now
2021 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #SN-PMA Emerald
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$3.99Buy it now
2022 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #SN-PMA
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$1.25Buy it now
2021 Panini Contenders Patrick Mahomes II Supernatural #SN-PMA Chiefs
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$0.990 bids · ends Nov 8
2022 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #SN-PMA Emerald
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$4.49Buy it now
2024 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #1 Degree 9💎
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$45.00Buy it now
2021 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #SN-PMA Ruby
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$1.99Buy it now
2024 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #1
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$20.00Buy it now
Panini 2024 Contenders Football Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #1 Chiefs
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$4.400 bids · ends Nov 5
2022 Panini Contenders #SN-PMA Patrick Mahomes II Supernatural F154
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.75Buy it now
2022 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #SN-PMA
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$3.00Buy it now
2024 Panini Contenders Patrick Mahomes II Supernatural #1 Chiefs
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$0.990 bids · ends Nov 8
2022 PANINI CONTENDERS SUPERNATURAL GREEN PATRICK MAHOMES KANSAS CITY CHIEFS
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$1.990 bids · ends Nov 9
2023 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #10
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$5.000 bids · ends Nov 10
2024 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #1
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$11.99Buy it now
Patrick Mahomes II 2023 Contenders Supernatural Kansas City Chiefs
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$11.50Buy it now
2021 Panini Contenders Patrick Mahomes II Supernatural #SN-PMA Kansas City Chief
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$1.99Buy it now
2024 Panini Contenders - Supernatural Patrick Mahomes II #1
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$5.502 bids · ends Nov 6
Parallels & grades
Patrick Mahomes Supernatural value by version
| Version | Listed | From | Median | PSA 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cracked Ice/25 | 2 | $300 | $325 | — |
| Sapphire | 1 | $300 | $300 | — |
| Orange | 1 | $99.95 | $99.95 | — |
| Gold | 1 | $64.99 | $64.99 | — |
| Refractor | 2 | $2.99 | $48.99 | — |
| Silver | 1 | $29.99 | $29.99 | — |
| Pink | 4 | $15.00 | $27.80 | — |
| Red | 1 | $7.99 | $7.99 | — |
Grouped from live listing titles · asking prices
Card back
Patrick Mahomes Supernatural value FAQ
- How much are Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards worth?
- Most Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards list between about $3 and $15 on eBay. Parallels like the Cracked Ice ask more (around $325), and condition, grade and print run move the value most.
- Which Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards are the most popular?
- By number of listings, the most popular are the 2024 Contenders #1 and 2023 Contenders #10.
- Are Patrick Mahomes Supernatural cards worth anything?
- Most list for a few dollars. The value is in rare parallels, low print runs, autographs and high grades (the Cracked Ice version lists around $325).