Rookie cards · Baseball
Aaron Judge Rookie Card Value
As of November 10, 2026, Aaron Judge rookie cards have a median eBay asking price of $27.99 across 77 live listings, with most listed between $8.99 and $89.99. Raw copies ask around $22.49 and PSA 10s around $223. The most expensive listed right now is "2017 Bowman Aaron Judge Rookie of the Year Favorites Chrome Auto Mojo Orange /25" at $7,700.
The most-listed Aaron Judge rookie cards are the 2017 Topps Chrome #169, 2017 Topps Update #US99 and 2017 Bowman #32. Typical asking prices run from about $9 to $90.
Listings as of · eBay asking prices, refreshed every 6 hours · How prices work
Listings link to eBay. As an eBay Partner, Card Value may earn a commission when you buy through these links.

Top listing right now
Median ask
$27.99
77 live listings
What's popular
How much are Aaron Judge rookie cards worth?
Most-listed aaron judge rookie cards
- 12017 Topps Chrome #169typ. $425
- 22017 Topps Update #US99typ. $80
- 32017 Bowman #32typ. $35
- 42015 Bowman #150 Mvp All-Startyp. $15
Chase cards
What are the most expensive Aaron Judge rookie cards?
#12017 Bowman Aaron Judge Rookie of the Year Favorites Chrome Auto Mojo Orange /25
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$7,700Buy it now
#2Aaron Judge 2015 Bowman Inception Prospect Autograph Rookie NY Yankees RC #PA-AJ
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$800Buy it now
#3BGS 9.5Aaron Judge Rookie #169 BGS 9.5 2017 Topps Chrome Refractor Baseball Card MLB
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$750Buy it now
#42017 Topps Aaron Judge RC Black Rookie Class ROY J5BK #/10 SSP PSA
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$595Buy it now
#5Topps 2017 Topps Chrome #169 Aaron Judge Catching Rookie Base Yankees MLB
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$421Buy it now
#6PSA 9MINTTopps 2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge #169 Pink Refractor Rookie PSA 9
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$415Buy it now
#7Topps 2017 Transcendent Topps History VIP Party Aaron Judge RC #AJ-1960 /87
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$350Buy it now
#8PSA 10GEM MT2017 Topps - Aaron Judge #287 Fielding RC Base Set PSA 10 Gem Mint Yankees
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$350Buy it now
On the market
More Aaron Judge rookie cards for sale

Topps 2017 Aaron Judge RC Rookie #147 *read description*
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.00Buy it now
Topps 2017 Topps Chrome Freshman Flash Aaron Judge Yankees #FF-11 RC Insert
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$47.00Buy it now
2017 Topps 1987 30th Anniversary Baseball #87-177 Aaron Judge Rookie Card RC
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$50.00Buy it now
2019 Bowman Chrome #90 Aaron Judge NY Yankees MLB
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.99Buy it now
2015 Bowman Draft AARON JUDGE Pre-Rookie Card #150 Yankees QTY Available
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$16.99Buy it now
AARON JUDGE 1st 2013 Bowman Draft Baseball New York Yankees Rookie Card RC QTY
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$144Buy it now
PSA 10GEM MT2017 Topps Update Aaron Judge RC Rookie PSA 10 GEM MINT
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$195Buy it now
Aaron Judge RC Topps 2017 National Baseball Card Day Stadium Promos #NYY-2
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$29.99Buy it now
PSA 9MINTAaron Judge PSA 9 - 2017 Topps #86 Throwback Thursday RC Rookie New York Yankees
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$130Buy it now
PSA 8NM-MT2017 TOPPS UPDATE ROOKIE DEBUT #US99 AARON JUDGE ROOKIE RC PSA 8
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$89.99Buy it now
PSA 9MINT2017 Topps Now MLB #654 Aaron Judge = RC Rookie = PSA 9 MINT = NY Yankees
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$47.00Buy it now
(2) different Alaska Rookie AARON JUDGE 2011 Yankees
New · + shipping on eBay
$4.99Buy it now
Aaron Judge ROOKIE RC TOPPS RARE INVESTMENT CARD BATTING MVP YANKEES MLB MINT
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$55.00Buy it now
2017 Topps Archives #62 Aaron Judge Yankees Rookie Card BAS Gem Mint 9.5
+ shipping on eBay
$293Buy it now
2017 Topps Fire #62 Aaron Judge RC rookie card + 15 bonus cards - NY Yankees
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$42.95Buy it now
2017 DDK Design - Aaron Judge RC - FREE SHIPPING
Used · + shipping on eBay
$2.75Buy it now
AARON JUDGE ALL-STAR ROOKIE CARD New York Yankees Baseball TOPPS FUTURE STARS!
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$0.990 bids · ends Nov 14
PSA 9MINTPanini 2017 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Aaron Judge #38 RC PSA 9 Yankees
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$94.00Buy it now
2017 RC AARON JUDGE & CODY BELLINGER #321 Topps NOW JUNE ROOKIES OF THE MONTH
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$15.00Buy it now
AARON JUDGE YOU CHOOSE YOUR CARD, ASSORTED YEARS & COMPANIES BASE & INSERTS
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$20.00Buy it now
PSA 10GEM MTPSA 10 2017 Topps Now Aaron Judge Rookie Card ⚾️🇺🇸
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$1.000 bids · ends Nov 15
2015 Leaf Baseball - Aaron Judge #01 (RC)
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$10.00Buy it now
Aaron Judge, Yankees, Refractor, Chrome, MLB, Topps, and Base - Pick Your Card!
Ungraded · + shipping on eBay
$2.49Buy it now
PSA 9MINT2017 Topps Chrome Aaron Judge 1987 Rookie RC #87T-8 New York Yankees PSA 9
Graded · + shipping on eBay
$150Buy it now
Parallels & grades
Aaron Judge value by version
| Version | Listed | From | Median | PSA 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mojo | 1 | $7,700 | $7,700 | — |
| Black | 1 | $595 | $595 | — |
| Pink | 1 | $415 | $415 | — |
| Refractor | 6 | $2.49 | $34.99 | — |
| Base / other | 67 | $0.99 | $26.55 | $223 |
| Gold | 1 | $6.99 | $6.99 | — |
Grouped from live listing titles · asking prices
Card back
Aaron Judge value FAQ
- How much are Aaron Judge rookie cards worth?
- Most Aaron Judge rookie cards list between about $9 and $90 on eBay. condition, grade and print run move the value most.
- Which Aaron Judge rookie cards are the most popular?
- By number of listings, the most popular are the 2017 Topps Chrome #169, 2017 Topps Update #US99, 2017 Bowman #32 and 2015 Bowman #150 Mvp All-Star.
- Are Aaron Judge rookie cards worth anything?
- Yes. A typical Aaron Judge rookie card lists for around $30, and graded, numbered or autographed copies go well beyond that.